Photo by Shutterstock 1393388951. Image of sulfur on a natural background sourced from Shutterstock. Available here
By Thomas Leung, DACM, Clinical Pharmacologist
As practitioners of Chinese medicine, we're no strangers to questions about the safety of herbal ingredients, including sulfites. This guide equips you with an essential understanding of sulfites and offers practical guidance for addressing patient concerns.
Sulfites Simplified: What Practitioners Need to Know
Sulfites are chemical compounds, distinct from elemental sulfur. They are FDA-approved for food preservation and are not true allergens, although they can be irritants in rare cases.
Example for Practice: When a patient is concerned about an "allergy to sulfur," clarify that sulfites in herbs are different from sulfa drugs like Bactrim or Septra.
Sulfites: They're Everywhere, Not Just in Your Herbs
Sulfites are not unique to Chinese medicine; they're ubiquitous in many food items and other products:
Where You'll Find Sulfites:
- Wine & Beer: To prevent oxidation and preserve flavor.
- Processed Meats: Like sausages and hot dogs.
- Bakery Goods: To condition dough.
- Snack Foods: In trail mix and chips.
- Condiments: In vinegar and molasses.
- Canned and Frozen Fruits: To preserve color and freshness.
Example for Practice: Discuss daily sulfite exposure with patients who consume processed foods, wine, or condiments.
Historical Use of Sulfites in Chinese Medicine
Sulfites have historically been used to preserve the quality of Chinese herbs:
How Sulfites Work in Herb Preservation:
- Anti-microbial Effect: Inhibiting harmful bacteria.
- Anti-fungal Properties: Warding off fungal growth.
- Pest Control: Keeping away worms and other pests.
- Color Retention: Maintaining herb potency and quality.
Example for Practice: Stress that sulfites are a traditional and necessary practice for ensuring herb quality and safety.
Different Forms of Chinese Medicine Herbs and Sulfites
It's primarily raw herbs that may contain sulfites. Herbal granules and tea pills are generally sulfite-free, as they go directly from harvest to factory processing.
- Raw Herbs: May contain sulfites.
- Herbal Granules: Typically sulfite-free.
- Tea Pills: Usually do not contain sulfites.
Example for Practice: For sulfite-sensitive patients, recommend herbal granules or tea pills as alternatives.
Understanding Sulfite Sensitivity
Contrary to popular belief, sulfite sensitivity is not an allergic reaction but an enzymatic deficiency. Less than 1% of the general population is sulfite-sensitive, and this percentage rises to around 5% among asthmatics.
Example for Practice: Use these statistics to demystify sulfite concerns and clarify that sulfite sensitivity is not an allergy but a rare enzymatic deficiency.
Sulfites in Chinese Medicine: Current Trends
Companies like Kamwo offer both traditional and sulfur-free raw herbs, and we're increasingly moving towards organic options.
Example for Practice: Offer patients the choice between traditional and sulfur-free raw herbs, reassuring them of both options' safety.
Taking Action: Practical Steps for Practitioners
1. Educate Staff: Ensure that everyone is aware of the FDA guidelines on sulfites.
2. Patient Education: Create a handy FAQ for concerned patients.
3. Offer Alternatives: Keep stock of sulfite-free options for sensitive patients.
4. Monitor and Document: Maintain records for patients reporting sulfite sensitivity.
Example for Practice: If a patient reports sensitivity, switch them to a sulfite-free formula and monitor the results.
Conclusion
Sulfites in Chinese medicine is a nuanced topic requiring ongoing education and patient management. This guide aims to assist you in that process, providing practical recommendations and actionable insights for practice.